Life Members
- Rev. Millard W. Mead
- Norma Coe Anderson
- Mrs. Mary Miller (deceased February 2001)
- Louise Morrison
- Mary Beard
- Rev. Marvin D. Bean
- Mrs. Willard A. Shaw
- William Drown
- Rev. Fred Gaston (deceased March 2004)
- George H. Theuer
- Dr.William Creasy
- Gladys Nicholas
- Dr. Paul Boase (deceased December 2000)
- Carol Beck
- Harriette Snoga (deceased August 2008)
- Robert L. George
- Susan J. Cohen (deceased January 2003)
- James Callihan
- Ruth Craig
- Louis Risser
- Jennie B. Lepley-Newton
- Detterman Log Church -- UMC Heritage Landmark (Bishop John Seybert/Flat Rock Cluster)
- Church of the Master UMC, Westerville, OH
- Hanby House -- UMC Heritage Landmark
- Dr. Roy Rauschenberg
- Beverly M. Miner
- Mary E. Ramser
- David W. Einsel, Jr. (deceased October 2006)
- Mary Fraser-Moots
- Phillip K. Moots (deceased April 2007)
- Rev. John W. Beers, by West Ohio A & H
- Rev. Millard J. Miller, D.D., by Westerville Historical Society
- Martha Sprout
- Richard W. Rash (deceased April 2002)
- Maurice Blue (deceased June 2002)
- Rev. Terry G. Washburn
- Dr. Allan W. Hall
- Rev. Don Trigg, by East Ohio A & H
- Arden Welch
- Ellen Roth
- Mary Mortimer, by Ebenezer Zane Cabin Committee
- Dicey Ann Carter-Crain
- Ann S. Miller
- Jennifer Neff, in memory of Neff-Noll-Sanzenbacher Families
- Katherine B. Fuller
- Rev. Lowell Peterson
- Joanne Miller
- Betsy Fletcher
- Bellpoint United Methodist Church
Memorials
Emmeline Miller, by Westerville Historical Sociey
Merrill E. Nelson, by Clenzo B. Fox
